Aluminum gutters remain the industry standard for good reasons. They're durable, rust-resistant, and can last 20+ years with proper maintenance. These gutters handle extreme temperatures well, won't crack in cold weather, and hold up against heavy rain and snow loads. Available in various colors, aluminum gutters can be painted to match your home's exterior.

The main drawback? They can dent from falling branches or ladders, and their color may fade over time. However, their durability and longevity often outweigh these concerns.

Vinyl gutters appeal to DIY homeowners and budget-conscious buyers. They're lightweight, easy to install, and won't rust or corrode. Initially less expensive than aluminum, vinyl gutters come in limited colors but maintain their appearance without painting.

However, vinyl has significant limitations. These gutters become brittle in extreme cold, can sag under heavy loads, and typically last only 10-15 years. UV exposure can cause fading and deterioration over time.

Installation costs typically range from $4-8 per linear foot for aluminum gutters and $3-5 per linear foot for vinyl, with vinyl being the more budget-friendly initial choice.

At Bartlett Contracting, LLC, we typically recommend aluminum gutters for their superior durability and longevity. While the initial investment is higher, aluminum gutters provide better value over time through reduced replacement needs and maintenance costs. Contact Bartlett Contracting, LLC today for a free professional assessment of your gutter needs and a customized recommendation for your home.